---
id: 5900f3c51000cf542c50fed7
title: 'Problem 89: Roman numerals'
challengeType: 5
forumTopicId: 302204
dashedName: problem-89-roman-numerals
---

# --description--

For a number written in Roman numerals to be considered valid there are basic rules which must be followed. Even though the rules allow some numbers to be expressed in more than one way there is always a "best" way of writing a particular number.

For example, it would appear that there are at least six ways of writing the number sixteen:

<div style="margin-left: 4em; font-family: 'courier new', monospace;">
  IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII<br>
  VIIIIIIIIIII<br>
  VVIIIIII<br>
  XIIIIII<br>
  VVVI<br>
  XVI<br>
</div>

However, according to the rules only XIIIIII and XVI are valid, and the last example is considered to be the most efficient, as it uses the least number of numerals.

The array, `roman`, contains one thousand numbers written in valid, but not necessarily minimal, Roman numerals; see [About... Roman Numerals](https://projecteuler.net/about=roman_numerals) for the definitive rules for this problem.

Find the number of characters saved by writing each of these in their minimal form.

**Note:** You can assume that all the Roman numerals in the array contain no more than four consecutive identical units.

# --hints--

`romanNumerals(roman)` should return a number.

```js
assert(typeof romanNumerals(roman) === 'number');
```

`romanNumerals(roman)` should return 743.

```js
assert.strictEqual(romanNumerals(roman), 743);
```

# --seed--

## --seed-contents--

```js
function romanNumerals(arr) {

  return true;
}

// Only change code above this line

const roman = [
  'MMMMDCLXXII','MMDCCCLXXXIII','MMMDLXVIIII','MMMMDXCV','DCCCLXXII','MMCCCVI','MMMCDLXXXVII','MMMMCCXXI','MMMCCXX','MMMMDCCCLXXIII','MMMCCXXXVII','MMCCCLXXXXIX','MDCCCXXIIII','MMCXCVI','CCXCVIII','MMMCCCXXXII','MDCCXXX','MMMDCCCL','MMMMCCLXXXVI','MMDCCCXCVI','MMMDCII','MMMCCXII','MMMMDCCCCI','MMDCCCXCII','MDCXX','CMLXXXVII','MMMXXI','MMMMCCCXIV','MLXXII','MCCLXXVIIII','MMMMCCXXXXI','MMDCCCLXXII','MMMMXXXI','MMMDCCLXXX','MMDCCCLXXIX','MMMMLXXXV','MCXXI','MDCCCXXXVII','MMCCCLXVII','MCDXXXV','CCXXXIII','CMXX','MMMCLXIV','MCCCLXXXVI','DCCCXCVIII','MMMDCCCCXXXIV','CDXVIIII','MMCCXXXV','MDCCCXXXII','MMMMD','MMDCCLXIX','MMMMCCCLXXXXVI','MMDCCXLII','MMMDCCCVIIII','DCCLXXXIIII','MDCCCCXXXII','MMCXXVII','DCCCXXX','CCLXIX','MMMXI','MMMMCMLXXXXVIII','MMMMDLXXXVII','MMMMDCCCLX','MMCCLIV','CMIX','MMDCCCLXXXIIII','CLXXXII','MMCCCCXXXXV','MMMMDLXXXVIIII','MMMDCCCXXI','MMDCCCCLXXVI','MCCCCLXX','MMCDLVIIII','MMMDCCCLIX','MMMMCCCCXIX','MMMDCCCLXXV','XXXI','CDLXXXIII','MMMCXV','MMDCCLXIII','MMDXXX','MMMMCCCLVII','MMMDCI','MMMMCDLXXXIIII','MMMMCCCXVI','CCCLXXXVIII','MMMMCML','MMMMXXIV','MMMCCCCXXX','DCCX','MMMCCLX','MMDXXXIII','CCCLXIII','MMDCCXIII','MMMCCCXLIV','CLXXXXI','CXVI','MMMMCXXXIII','CLXX','DCCCXVIII','MLXVII','DLXXXX','MMDXXI','MMMMDLXXXXVIII','MXXII','LXI','DCCCCXLIII','MMMMDV','MMMMXXXIV','MDCCCLVIII','MMMCCLXXII','MMMMDCCXXXVI','MMMMLXXXIX','MDCCCLXXXI','MMMMDCCCXV','MMMMCCCCXI','MMMMCCCLIII','MDCCCLXXI','MMCCCCXI','MLXV','MMCDLXII','MMMMDXXXXII','MMMMDCCCXL','MMMMCMLVI','CCLXXXIV','MMMDCCLXXXVI','MMCLII','MMMCCCCXV','MMLXXXIII','MMMV','MMMV','DCCLXII','MMDCCCCXVI','MMDCXLVIII','CCLIIII','CCCXXV','MMDCCLXXXVIIII','MMMMDCLXXVIII','MMMMDCCCXCI','MMMMCCCXX','MMCCXLV','MMMDCCCLXIX','MMCCLXIIII','MMMDCCCXLIX','MMMMCCCLXIX','CMLXXXXI','MCMLXXXIX','MMCDLXI','MMDCLXXVIII','MMMMDCCLXI','MCDXXV','DL','CCCLXXII','MXVIIII','MCCCCLXVIII','CIII','MMMDCCLXXIIII','MMMDVIII','MMMMCCCLXXXXVII','MMDXXVII','MMDCCLXXXXV','MMMMCXLVI','MMMDCCLXXXII','MMMDXXXVI','MCXXII','CLI','DCLXXXIX','MMMCLI','MDCLXIII','MMMMDCCXCVII','MMCCCLXXXV','MMMDCXXVIII','MMMCDLX','MMMCMLII','MMMIV','MMMMDCCCLVIII','MMMDLXXXVIII','MCXXIV','MMMMLXXVI','CLXXIX','MMMCCCCXXVIIII','DCCLXXXV','MMMDCCCVI','LI','CLXXXVI','MMMMCCCLXXVI','MCCCLXVI','CCXXXIX','MMDXXXXI','MMDCCCXLI','DCCCLXXXVIII','MMMMDCCCIV','MDCCCCXV','MMCMVI','MMMMCMLXXXXV','MMDCCLVI','MMMMCCXLVIII','DCCCCIIII','MMCCCCIII','MMMDCCLXXXVIIII','MDCCCLXXXXV','DVII','MMMV','DCXXV','MMDCCCXCV','DCVIII','MMCDLXVI','MCXXVIII','MDCCXCVIII','MMDCLX','MMMDCCLXIV','MMCDLXXVII','MMDLXXXIIII','MMMMCCCXXII','MMMDCCCXLIIII','DCCCCLXVII','MMMCLXXXXIII','MCCXV','MMMMDCXI','MMMMDCLXXXXV','MMMCCCLII','MMCMIX','MMDCCXXV','MMDLXXXVI','MMMMDCXXVIIII','DCCCCXXXVIIII','MMCCXXXIIII','MMDCCLXXVIII','MDCCLXVIIII','MMCCLXXXV','MMMMDCCCLXXXVIII','MMCMXCI','MDXLII','MMMMDCCXIV','MMMMLI','DXXXXIII','MMDCCXI','MMMMCCLXXXIII','MMMDCCCLXXIII','MDCLVII','MMCD','MCCCXXVII','MMMMDCCIIII','MMMDCCXLVI','MMMCLXXXVII','MMMCCVIIII','MCCCCLXXIX','DL','DCCCLXXVI','MMDXCI','MMMMDCCCCXXXVI','MMCII','MMMDCCCXXXXV','MMMCDXLV','MMDCXXXXIV','MMD','MDCCCLXXXX','MMDCXLIII','MMCCXXXII','MMDCXXXXVIIII','DCCCLXXI','MDXCVIIII','MMMMCCLXXVIII','MDCLVIIII','MMMCCCLXXXIX','MDCLXXXV','MDLVIII','MMMMCCVII','MMMMDCXIV','MMMCCCLXIIII','MMIIII','MMMMCCCLXXIII','CCIII','MMMCCLV','MMMDXIII','MMMCCCXC','MMMDCCCXXI','MMMMCCCCXXXII','CCCLVI','MMMCCCLXXXVI','MXVIIII','MMMCCCCXIIII','CLXVII','MMMCCLXX','CCCCLXIV','MMXXXXII','MMMMCCLXXXX','MXL','CCXVI','CCCCLVIIII','MMCCCII','MCCCLVIII','MMMMCCCX','MCDLXXXXIV','MDCCCXIII','MMDCCCXL','MMMMCCCXXIII','DXXXIV','CVI','MMMMDCLXXX','DCCCVII','MMCMLXIIII','MMMDCCCXXXIII','DCCC','MDIII','MMCCCLXVI','MMMCCCCLXXI','MMDCCCCXVIII','CCXXXVII','CCCXXV','MDCCCXII','MMMCMV','MMMMCMXV','MMMMDCXCI','DXXI','MMCCXLVIIII','MMMMCMLII','MDLXXX','MMDCLXVI','CXXI','MMMDCCCLIIII','MMMCXXI','MCCIII','MMDCXXXXI','CCXCII','MMMMDXXXV','MMMCCCLXV','MMMMDLXV','MMMCCCCXXXII','MMMCCCVIII','DCCCCLXXXXII','MMCLXIV','MMMMCXI','MLXXXXVII','MMMCDXXXVIII','MDXXII','MLV','MMMMDLXVI','MMMCXII','XXXIII','MMMMDCCCXXVI','MMMLXVIIII','MMMLX','MMMCDLXVII','MDCCCLVII','MMCXXXVII','MDCCCCXXX','MMDCCCLXIII','MMMMDCXLIX','MMMMCMXLVIII','DCCCLXXVIIII','MDCCCLIII','MMMCMLXI','MMMMCCLXI','MMDCCCLIII','MMMDCCCVI','MMDXXXXIX','MMCLXXXXV','MMDXXX','MMMXIII','DCLXXIX','DCCLXII','MMMMDCCLXVIII','MDCCXXXXIII','CCXXXII','MMMMDCXXV','MMMCCCXXVIII','MDCVIII','MMMCLXXXXIIII','CLXXXI','MDCCCCXXXIII','MMMMDCXXX','MMMDCXXIV','MMMCCXXXVII','MCCCXXXXIIII','CXVIII','MMDCCCCIV','MMMMCDLXXV','MMMDLXIV','MDXCIII','MCCLXXXI','MMMDCCCXXIV','MCXLIII','MMMDCCCI','MCCLXXX','CCXV','MMDCCLXXI','MMDLXXXIII','MMMMDCXVII','MMMCMLXV','MCLXVIII','MMMMCCLXXVI','MMMDCCLXVIIII','MMMMDCCCIX','DLXXXXIX','DCCCXXII','MMMMIII','MMMMCCCLXXVI','DCCCXCIII','DXXXI','MXXXIIII','CCXII','MMMDCCLXXXIIII','MMMCXX','MMMCMXXVII','DCCCXXXX','MMCDXXXVIIII','MMMMDCCXVIII','LV','MMMDCCCCVI','MCCCII','MMCMLXVIIII','MDCCXI','MMMMDLXVII','MMCCCCLXI','MMDCCV','MMMCCCXXXIIII','MMMMDI','MMMDCCCXCV','MMDCCLXXXXI','MMMDXXVI','MMMDCCCLVI','MMDCXXX','MCCCVII','MMMMCCCLXII','MMMMXXV','MMCMXXV','MMLVI','MMDXXX','MMMMCVII','MDC','MCCIII','MMMMDCC','MMCCLXXV','MMDCCCXXXXVI','MMMMCCCLXV','CDXIIII','MLXIIII','CCV','MMMCMXXXI','CCCCLXVI','MDXXXII','MMMMCCCLVIII','MMV','MMMCLII','MCMLI','MMDCCXX','MMMMCCCCXXXVI','MCCLXXXI','MMMCMVI','DCCXXX','MMMMCCCLXV','DCCCXI','MMMMDCCCXIV','CCCXXI','MMDLXXV','CCCCLXXXX','MCCCLXXXXII','MMDCIX','DCCXLIIII','DXIV','MMMMCLII','CDLXI','MMMCXXVII','MMMMDCCCCLXIII','MMMDCLIIII','MCCCCXXXXII','MMCCCLX','CCCCLIII','MDCCLXXVI','MCMXXIII','MMMMDLXXVIII','MMDCCCCLX','MMMCCCLXXXX','MMMCDXXVI','MMMDLVIII','CCCLXI','MMMMDCXXII','MMDCCCXXI','MMDCCXIII','MMMMCLXXXVI','MDCCCCXXVI','MDV','MMDCCCCLXXVI','MMMMCCXXXVII','MMMDCCLXXVIIII','MMMCCCCLXVII','DCCXLI','MMCLXXXVIII','MCCXXXVI','MMDCXLVIII','MMMMCXXXII','MMMMDCCLXVI','MMMMCMLI','MMMMCLXV','MMMMDCCCXCIV','MCCLXXVII','LXXVIIII','DCCLII','MMMCCCXCVI','MMMCLV','MMDCCCXXXXVIII','DCCCXV','MXC','MMDCCLXXXXVII','MMMMCML','MMDCCCLXXVIII','DXXI','MCCCXLI','DCLXXXXI','MMCCCLXXXXVIII','MDCCCCLXXVIII','MMMMDXXV','MMMDCXXXVI','MMMCMXCVII','MMXVIIII','MMMDCCLXXIV','MMMCXXV','DXXXVIII','MMMMCLXVI','MDXII','MMCCCLXX','CCLXXI','DXIV','MMMCLIII','DLII','MMMCCCXLIX','MMCCCCXXVI','MMDCXLIII','MXXXXII','CCCLXXXV','MDCLXXVI','MDCXII','MMMCCCLXXXIII','MMDCCCCLXXXII','MMMMCCCLXXXV','MMDCXXI','DCCCXXX','MMMDCCCCLII','MMMDCCXXII','MMMMCDXCVIII','MMMCCLXVIIII','MMXXV','MMMMCDXIX','MMMMCCCX','MMMCCCCLXVI','MMMMDCLXXVIIII','MMMMDCXXXXIV','MMMCMXII','MMMMXXXIII','MMMMDLXXXII','DCCCLIV','MDXVIIII','MMMCLXXXXV','CCCCXX','MMDIX','MMCMLXXXVIII','DCCXLIII','DCCLX','D','MCCCVII','MMMMCCCLXXXIII','MDCCCLXXIIII','MMMDCCCCLXXXVII','MMMMCCCVII','MMMDCCLXXXXVI','CDXXXIV','MCCLXVIII','MMMMDLX','MMMMDXII','MMMMCCCCLIIII','MCMLXXXXIII','MMMMDCCCIII','MMDCLXXXIII','MDCCCXXXXIV','XXXXVII','MMMDCCCXXXII','MMMDCCCXLII','MCXXXV','MDCXXVIIII','MMMCXXXXIIII','MMMMCDXVII','MMMDXXIII','MMMMCCCCLXI','DCLXXXXVIIII','LXXXXI','CXXXIII','MCDX','MCCLVII','MDCXXXXII','MMMCXXIV','MMMMLXXXX','MMDCCCCXLV','MLXXX','MMDCCCCLX','MCDLIII','MMMCCCLXVII','MMMMCCCLXXIV','MMMDCVIII','DCCCCXXIII','MMXCI','MMDCCIV','MMMMDCCCXXXIV','CCCLXXI','MCCLXXXII','MCMIII','CCXXXI','DCCXXXVIII','MMMMDCCXLVIIII','MMMMCMXXXV','DCCCLXXV','DCCXCI','MMMMDVII','MMMMDCCCLXVIIII','CCCXCV','MMMMDCCXX','MCCCCII','MMMCCCXC','MMMCCCII','MMDCCLXXVII','MMDCLIIII','CCXLIII','MMMDCXVIII','MMMCCCIX','MCXV','MMCCXXV','MLXXIIII','MDCCXXVI','MMMCCCXX','MMDLXX','MMCCCCVI','MMDCCXX','MMMMDCCCCXCV','MDCCCXXXII','MMMMDCCCCXXXX','XCIV','MMCCCCLX','MMXVII','MLXXI','MMMDXXVIII','MDCCCCII','MMMCMLVII','MMCLXXXXVIII','MDCCCCLV','MCCCCLXXIIII','MCCCLII','MCDXLVI','MMMMDXVIII','DCCLXXXIX','MMMDCCLXIV','MDCCCCXLIII','CLXXXXV','MMMMCCXXXVI','MMMDCCCXXI','MMMMCDLXXVII','MCDLIII','MMCCXLVI','DCCCLV','MCDLXX','DCLXXVIII','MMDCXXXIX','MMMMDCLX','MMDCCLI','MMCXXXV','MMMCCXII','MMMMCMLXII','MMMMCCV','MCCCCLXIX','MMMMCCIII','CLXVII','MCCCLXXXXIIII','MMMMDCVIII','MMDCCCLXI','MMLXXIX','CMLXIX','MMDCCCXLVIIII','DCLXII','MMMCCCXLVII','MDCCCXXXV','MMMMDCCXCVI','DCXXX','XXVI','MMLXIX','MMCXI','DCXXXVII','MMMMCCCXXXXVIII','MMMMDCLXI','MMMMDCLXXIIII','MMMMVIII','MMMMDCCCLXII','MDCXCI','MMCCCXXIIII','CCCCXXXXV','MMDCCCXXI','MCVI','MMDCCLXVIII','MMMMCXL','MLXVIII','CMXXVII','CCCLV','MDCCLXXXIX','MMMCCCCLXV','MMDCCLXII','MDLXVI','MMMCCCXVIII','MMMMCCLXXXI','MMCXXVII','MMDCCCLXVIII','MMMCXCII','MMMMDCLVIII','MMMMDCCCXXXXII','MMDCCCCLXXXXVI','MDCCXL','MDCCLVII','MMMMDCCCLXXXVI','DCCXXXIII','MMMMDCCCCLXXXV','MMCCXXXXVIII','MMMCCLXXVIII','MMMDCLXXVIII','DCCCI','MMMMLXXXXVIIII','MMMCCCCLXXII','MMCLXXXVII','CCLXVI','MCDXLIII','MMCXXVIII','MDXIV','CCCXCVIII','CLXXVIII','MMCXXXXVIIII','MMMDCLXXXIV','CMLVIII','MCDLIX','MMMMDCCCXXXII','MMMMDCXXXIIII','MDCXXI','MMMDCXLV','MCLXXVIII','MCDXXII','IV','MCDLXXXXIII','MMMMDCCLXV','CCLI','MMMMDCCCXXXVIII','DCLXII','MCCCLXVII','MMMMDCCCXXXVI','MMDCCXLI','MLXI','MMMCDLXVIII','MCCCCXCIII','XXXIII','MMMDCLXIII','MMMMDCL','DCCCXXXXIIII','MMDLVII','DXXXVII','MCCCCXXIIII','MCVII','MMMMDCCXL','MMMMCXXXXIIII','MCCCCXXIV','MMCLXVIII','MMXCIII','MDCCLXXX','MCCCLIIII','MMDCLXXI','MXI','MCMLIV','MMMCCIIII','DCCLXXXVIIII','MDCLIV','MMMDCXIX','CMLXXXI','DCCLXXXVII','XXV','MMMXXXVI','MDVIIII','CLXIII','MMMCDLVIIII','MMCCCCVII','MMMLXX','MXXXXII','MMMMCCCLXVIII','MMDCCCXXVIII','MMMMDCXXXXI','MMMMDCCCXXXXV','MMMXV','MMMMCCXVIIII','MMDCCXIIII','MMMXXVII','MDCCLVIIII','MMCXXIIII','MCCCLXXIV','DCLVIII','MMMLVII','MMMCXLV','MMXCVII','MMMCCCLXXXVII','MMMMCCXXII','DXII','MMMDLV','MCCCLXXVIII','MMMCLIIII','MMMMCLXXXX','MMMCLXXXIIII','MDCXXIII','MMMMCCXVI','MMMMDLXXXIII','MMMDXXXXIII','MMMMCCCCLV','MMMDLXXXI','MMMCCLXXVI','MMMMXX','MMMMDLVI','MCCCCLXXX','MMMXXII','MMXXII','MMDCCCCXXXI','MMMDXXV','MMMDCLXXXVIIII','MMMDLXXXXVII','MDLXIIII','CMXC','MMMXXXVIII','MDLXXXVIII','MCCCLXXVI','MMCDLIX','MMDCCCXVIII','MDCCCXXXXVI','MMMMCMIV','MMMMDCIIII','MMCCXXXV','XXXXVI','MMMMCCXVII','MMCCXXIV','MCMLVIIII','MLXXXIX','MMMMLXXXIX','CLXXXXIX','MMMDCCCCLVIII','MMMMCCLXXIII','MCCCC','DCCCLIX','MMMCCCLXXXII','MMMCCLXVIIII','MCLXXXV','CDLXXXVII','DCVI','MMX','MMCCXIII','MMMMDCXX','MMMMXXVIII','DCCCLXII','MMMMCCCXLIII','MMMMCLXV','DXCI','MMMMCLXXX','MMMDCCXXXXI','MMMMXXXXVI','DCLX','MMMCCCXI','MCCLXXX','MMCDLXXII','DCCLXXI','MMMCCCXXXVI','MCCCCLXXXVIIII','CDLVIII','DCCLVI','MMMMDCXXXVIII','MMCCCLXXXIII','MMMMDCCLXXV','MMMXXXVI','CCCLXXXXIX','CV','CCCCXIII','CCCCXVI','MDCCCLXXXIIII','MMDCCLXXXII','MMMMCCCCLXXXI','MXXV','MMCCCLXXVIIII','MMMCCXII','MMMMCCXXXIII','MMCCCLXXXVI','MMMDCCCLVIIII','MCCXXXVII','MDCLXXV','XXXV','MMDLI','MMMCCXXX','MMMMCXXXXV','CCCCLIX','MMMMDCCCLXXIII','MMCCCXVII','DCCCXVI','MMMCCCXXXXV','MDCCCCXCV','CLXXXI','MMMMDCCLXX','MMMDCCCIII','MMCLXXVII','MMMDCCXXIX','MMDCCCXCIIII','MMMCDXXIIII','MMMMXXVIII','MMMMDCCCCLXVIII','MDCCCXX','MMMMCDXXI','MMMMDLXXXIX','CCXVI','MDVIII','MMCCLXXI','MMMDCCCLXXI','MMMCCCLXXVI','MMCCLXI','MMMMDCCCXXXIV','DLXXXVI','MMMMDXXXII','MMMXXIIII','MMMMCDIV','MMMMCCCXLVIII','MMMMCXXXVIII','MMMCCCLXVI','MDCCXVIII','MMCXX','CCCLIX','MMMMDCCLXXII','MDCCCLXXV','MMMMDCCCXXIV','DCCCXXXXVIII','MMMDCCCCXXXVIIII','MMMMCCXXXV','MDCLXXXIII','MMCCLXXXIV','MCLXXXXIIII','DXXXXIII','MCCCXXXXVIII','MMCLXXIX','MMMMCCLXIV','MXXII','MMMCXIX','MDCXXXVII','MMDCCVI','MCLXXXXVIII','MMMCXVI','MCCCLX','MMMCDX','CCLXVIIII','MMMCCLX','MCXXVIII','LXXXII','MCCCCLXXXI','MMMI','MMMCCCLXIV','MMMCCCXXVIIII','CXXXVIII','MMCCCXX','MMMCCXXVIIII','MCCLXVI','MMMCCCCXXXXVI','MMDCCXCIX','MCMLXXI','MMCCLXVIII','CDLXXXXIII','MMMMDCCXXII','MMMMDCCLXXXVII','MMMDCCLIV','MMCCLXIII','MDXXXVII','DCCXXXIIII','MCII','MMMDCCCLXXI','MMMLXXIII','MDCCCLIII','MMXXXVIII','MDCCXVIIII','MDCCCCXXXVII','MMCCCXVI','MCMXXII','MMMCCCLVIII','MMMMDCCCXX','MCXXIII','MMMDLXI','MMMMDXXII','MDCCCX','MMDXCVIIII','MMMDCCCCVIII','MMMMDCCCCXXXXVI','MMDCCCXXXV','MMCXCIV','MCMLXXXXIII','MMMCCCLXXVI','MMMMDCLXXXV','CMLXIX','DCXCII','MMXXVIII','MMMMCCCXXX','XXXXVIIII'
];

romanNumerals(roman);
```

# --solutions--

```js
// solution required
```
